Founder hiring
Build a focused interview scorecard for an early-stage role
Choose relevant evidence before interviews so decisions are easier to explain and compare.

An interview scorecard is a record of the evidence you intend to review. It should help the founder stay connected with the role brief, rather than create a numerical result that appears more precise than the conversation supports.
Choose a few role-relevant criteria
Start with the work the person will actually do. Identify the skills, judgement or experience that matter at the beginning of the role. Separate essential requirements from qualities the team is prepared to develop.
For each criterion, describe the evidence you want to hear or see. A relevant project explanation may be more useful than a general question about being passionate or hardworking.
Use comparable questions
Prepare a common structure with room for meaningful follow-up. Tell candidates what the conversation or task involves and how much time to set aside.
Record examples from the candidate’s answer. Distinguish observed evidence from an interviewer’s impression, and note when a question was not explored sufficiently to support a conclusion.
Review the scorecard as a decision aid
Compare the evidence with the criteria and discuss important uncertainties. If another conversation or work sample is needed, explain the purpose and keep the request proportionate to the role.
Do not treat a total score as a substitute for checking the notes. The founder should be able to explain why the evidence supports the next hiring decision.
Example criterion
“Can explain a relevant problem, their own contribution and how they checked the result.” The interview note should capture the example offered and any clarification still needed.
Scorecard checklist
- Link each criterion to the role brief.
- Define the evidence you want to review.
- Use a consistent conversation structure.
- Separate evidence, impressions and unanswered questions.
- Explain the decision in terms of the role.
Keep the resulting review organised through applicant tracking.


