College partnerships
Review a college partnership pilot with useful evidence
Focus the review on the agreed activity, coordination experience and decisions about the next stage.

A pilot review should help the college decide what to continue, change or discuss next. The most useful evidence relates to the scope the institution actually agreed to run.
Return to the original questions
Begin with the preparation objective and cohort. Compare the activity that took place with the planned introduction, access arrangement and review process. This establishes a shared starting point before the teams discuss individual impressions.
Separate operational observations from student outcomes. Repeated questions about access instructions may indicate a communication issue. Faculty comments about unclear project descriptions may suggest a different resume-review activity. Those findings call for different next actions.
Collect specific feedback
Ask coordinators and participating faculty what was straightforward, what required additional explanation and what they would change. Where student feedback is included, use the institution’s agreed approach and collect only the information needed for the review.
Look for examples that explain the observation. “Students asked which cohort was eligible” is more actionable than “communication could improve.” Keep personal information out of a general review summary where it is unnecessary.
Turn findings into decisions
Record the change, the owner and the point at which it will be reviewed. A wider rollout should be a separate scope discussion, with the proposed departments, dates and benefits confirmed rather than assumed from the pilot.
Keep a concise summary of agreed decisions. This gives the college a reference for internal planning and helps the partner respond to the specific changes requested.
Example review finding
“The resume introduction was clear, but faculty needed a common project-description checklist. For the next cohort, the placement team will prepare that checklist before the introduction and review whether it reduces repeated clarification questions.”
Review checklist
- Restate the agreed objective and cohort.
- Compare planned and completed activities.
- Collect specific coordination and preparation feedback.
- Assign owners to the changes you agree.
- Treat expansion as a new scope decision.
See the college partnership approach when planning the next discussion.


